off the charts

You are here

Trump Budget Would Cut Non-Defense Programs to Half Their 2010 Level

May 23, 2017 at 3:45 PM

The Trump budget would radically cut non-defense discretionary (NDD) programs — the budget category that funds education, job training, medical research, and other investments that spur greater economic growth and higher living standards. The proposed cuts to NDD programs, which have already been squeezed in recent years, are nothing short of startling:

  • The budget would cut total NDD funding by 13 percent next year, after adjusting for inflation, bringing the total cut since 2010 to 25 percent. It would cut NDD further in later years so that by 2027, NDD funding would be just half its 2010 level (see graph).
  • The budget would increase or protect some NDD areas, such as veterans’ affairs and homeland security, which would require cutting other NDD programs by about one-third from their 2010 level, on average, in 2018.
  • The budget would take NDD spending next year to its lowest level in at least six decades as a percentage of the economy and, by 2027, to its lowest on that basis since the Hoover Administration — possibly even earlier.


NDD programs support investments that fuel economic growth and raise living standards and the quality of life for American individuals and families, including medical and scientific research, job training, elementary and secondary education, infrastructure improvements, and college assistance for students of modest incomes. These programs also help families afford housing, health care, and other necessities. And they encompass many basic government services, such as air traffic control, law enforcement, weather forecasting and warnings, and claims processing for Social Security benefits.

These programs have suffered from considerable austerity for the past seven years, due largely to the 2011 Budget Control Act’s (BCA) tight caps on non-defense and defense appropriations and the additional sequestration budget cuts below those levels. President Trump’s budget would magnify that austerity many times over.

For 2018, the budget proposes a total of $462 billion for non-defense appropriations subject to the BCA caps. That’s $57 billion below the 2017 funding level. As noted, the inflation-adjusted cut is 13 percent below 2017 and 25 percent below 2010. Excluding the Departments of Veterans Affairs and Homeland Security — both of which the Trump budget would increase — the inflation-adjusted percent cuts are 17 percent below 2017 and 33 percent below 2010.

But that’s just the beginning. The budget then proposes steady year-to-year cuts until NDD funding falls to $385 billion in 2027 ($312 billion when expressed in constant 2018 dollars) — 41 percent below 2017 and 49 percent below 2010, adjusted for inflation. Assuming funding for the Departments of Veterans Affairs and Homeland Security grows with inflation between now and 2027, other NDD programs would be cut by at least 60 percent below their 2010 level. In sum, the budget proposes a staggering funding cut for services to the public, assistance to those in need, and investments in the future of the country and the economy.

Already, eroding appropriations levels over the past seven years have led to considerable shortfalls and unmet needs. Congress should reject the President’s proposed cuts below the BCA levels — just as it rejected, on a bipartisan basis, the President’s additional cuts when enacting final 2017 appropriations. Instead, lawmakers should pursue a bipartisan agreement to provide relief from the tight appropriations caps, as they’ve done for each of the previous five years.