MÁS ALLÁ DE LOS NÚMEROS
States Can Use Temporary Reprieve to Reduce Harm From Medicaid Work Requirement
As a result of growing pressure and the ongoing confusion that has made it difficult for states to implement the new Medicaid work requirement by the January 1 deadline, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) on November 13 gave states the option to elect a “hold harmless” period for the first six months of 2027. States will still be required to ask applicants and enrollees about whether they meet the work requirement, but they can opt not to deny or terminate coverage for people who don’t meet it.
While this is a welcome development, nothing can fix the Medicaid work requirement and prevent it from causing large coverage losses; Congress should repeal the requirement altogether. If that can’t be done quickly enough, Congress or the Trump Administration should implement a full delay across the country, or the Administration should grant widespread good-faith delays, outlined in statute, for states that won’t be ready to begin implementation.
In contrast to the hold harmless option, a full delay would better insulate Medicaid enrollees and applicants from the red tape that comes with work requirements by not requiring states to ask questions and send notices related to the work requirement until full implementation. As it is, many people will still have to answer questions and contend with notices related to the work requirement during the hold harmless period. The chaos and confusion that are hallmarks of this policy will continue to put people’s health care at risk.
For now, states should take the following steps to maximize the protection people get during the hold harmless period. All states with residents subject to the work requirement should:
- Adopt the hold harmless period for the full six months allowed. No state had sufficient time to prepare to implement the massive changes required by the work requirement. Applying the requirement before a state has time to change and test systems, modify forms and notices, train workers, and communicate with stakeholders will cause even more people to lose coverage. States should adopt the hold harmless provision to reduce the harm from the work requirement — and protect the state from errors related to the rushed implementation. (If states adopt the hold harmless provision, they won’t face penalties from work requirement-related errors made while it is in effect.) States must notify CMS by December 11 if they plan to elect this option. They can apply it to applications submitted and renewals initiated through June 30, 2027.
- Communicate with impacted people proactively and clearly. The hold harmless provision adds yet another complicated layer on top of an exceedingly complex policy, so clear communication is essential. States are unlikely to have enough time to change the notices they are planning to send enrollees about the work requirement to clearly explain the new hold harmless provision. Therefore, they should insert a cover sheet with the notices, send additional correspondence, or otherwise communicate to applicants and enrollees that, despite what the notices may say, individuals can continue to get coverage for a time even if they don’t meet the work requirement. This is critical to preventing the “chilling effect” of the work requirement: without more information, many people might decide not to apply or renew coverage because they incorrectly assume they won’t be eligible.
- Carefully identify the people protected by the hold harmless provision and make sure they are covered. Consistent with the November 13 guidance, states should enroll and renew people who are eligible for Medicaid except for the work requirement while the hold harmless provision is in effect. This means applicants and enrollees who don’t submit information about their exemption from or compliance with the work requirement, or don’t send in related verification, should receive Medicaid if they are otherwise eligible, (even if they would otherwise be denied for procedural reasons, such as not sending in a form or verification document). States should not restrict the hold harmless provision only to people who returned all the work requirement paperwork but don’t have enough work hours to comply or don’t identify an exemption.
- Use the hold harmless period to identify gaps in implementation. While any Medicaid work requirement harms eligible people and can’t be fixed, states can use the hold harmless period to identify changes needed before full implementation to reduce the harm from the policy. States can identify people who would have been denied or lost coverage if it weren’t for the hold harmless provision and analyze the characteristics and circumstances of this population. They can then use this information to improve outreach, forms, and the use of data sources to better serve this population before the hold harmless period ends.
The optional hold harmless provision is an important development that will temporarily reduce the harm of the Medicaid work requirement, provided that already beleaguered states are able to operationalize it just seven weeks before the implementation deadline. But as that deadline ticks closer, federal action is needed to fully postpone the impact or, better yet, to repeal altogether what continued evidence and implementation hurdles have shown to be an unworkable policy and protect people’s access to health care.