January 13, 2005
’S TABOR CREATING JOBS? COLORADO
By Nicholas Johnson and Karen Lyons
PDF of full report If you cannot access the files through the links, right-click on the underlined text, click "Save Link As," download to your directory, and open the document in Adobe Acrobat Reader.
Advocates of Colorado’s “
Taxpayer Bill of Rights” (TABOR) — a stringent set of tax and spending limitations that is being promoted as a model for other states and for the federal government — sometimes selectively cite economic data to suggest that Colorado’s TABOR has boosted the state’s economy. A broader look at economic data suggests TABOR has created no jobs, and may have made things worse.
An honest accounting of
’s economic performance under TABOR must take into account the period since the recession began in March, 2001. Colorado
- In the last 44 months,
has lost 68,000 jobs, a decline of 3.0 percent — among the half-dozen largest losses of jobs in the country. Colorado
- Per-capita personal income has fallen 3.7 percent after inflation, a sharper drop than in any other state.
has been losing jobs, every other Colorado state has been adding jobs. Among all eight Mountain states ( Rocky Mountain , Arizona , Colorado , Idaho , Montana , Nevada , New Mexico and Utah ), the median job growth has been 4.5 percent. None of those other states has a strict TABOR limit. Wyoming
Overall since TABOR’s 1992 enactment,
’s growth has been merely average compared with its Colorado neighbors. In those 12 years — just as in the 12 years prior to TABOR’s enactment — Rocky Mountain employment rose at a fairly typical rate for a Mountain state. Colorado
- From 1980 to 1992, total nonfarm employment in
grew at an annual rate of 2.1 percent — equal to the median growth rate among all eight Colorado Rocky Mountain states.
- From 1992 to 2004, employment in
grew at an annual rate of 2.5 percent. The median growth among all eight Colorado Rocky Mountain statesduring this period was 2.7 percent. Job growth in since TABOR’s enactment was lower than the growth in four states in the region and higher than growth in three others. Colorado
(Note that the 1980-92 period included three national recessions, while the 1992-2004 period included only one, which explains why growth was better in Colorado and in other Rocky Mountain states in the latter period.)
Job Growth or Loss in Mountain States
Since Recession Began (March 2001 – November 2004)
Change in payroll employment (000)
Mountain States median
Source: Economic Policy Institute from BLS data.
In short, there is no clear correlation between TABOR and economic performance in
. TABOR did not cause most of Colorado ’s current economic problems, any more than TABOR caused the state’s economic growth in the 1990s. Rather, Colorado ’s nonpartisan Legislative Council Staff has found that both the economic boom of the 1990s and the bust of the last several years reflect the nature of Colorado ’s economy, and have little to do with fiscal policy. Colorado
Job Growth in Mountain States Before & After TABOR
Mountain States median
Average annual growth rates.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics.
What TABOR perhaps can be blamed for is exacerbating the boom-and-bust cycle in state finances — and perhaps in overall employment as well. Because TABOR required very large tax refunds in the boom years, the state was unable to put money into a rainy day fund or make other investments that could have eased the crisis when it arrived. It may well be that the TABOR-driven tax cuts during the boom years helped overheat the state’s economy, while large TABOR-driven budget cuts during the recession worsened the job loss by withdrawing demand from the economy at a time when it already was weak.